Insurance Adjuster Tactics — 7 Things They Won't Tell You
The adjuster who calls after your accident is not on your side. Their job is to close your claim for as little as possible. Here are the tactics they use — and exactly what to say back.
The Adjuster's Real Job
Insurance adjusters are employees of the insurance company — not neutral parties. They are trained negotiators with one goal: resolve your claim for the lowest amount the company can get away with. They are polite because it works. They call quickly because early settlements are cheap settlements. Every question they ask, every form they send, and every offer they make is designed to protect the company's bottom line, not yours.
That does not mean every adjuster is dishonest. But understanding their playbook is the single most important thing you can do to protect your claim.
7 Tactics Adjusters Use to Pay You Less
1. The Quick Settlement Offer
Within days of your accident, the adjuster calls with a check. It sounds generous because you haven't seen a medical bill yet. That's the point. Soft tissue injuries, herniated discs, and concussion symptoms can take weeks to surface. Once you cash that check, you cannot go back for more.
What to say
"I appreciate the offer, but I'm still receiving medical treatment. I'm not in a position to discuss settlement until I understand the full extent of my injuries."
2. The Recorded Statement
The adjuster asks to "take a quick recorded statement so we can process your claim faster." What they're actually doing is locking you into a version of events they can use against you. If you say "I'm doing okay" out of politeness, that becomes evidence that you weren't seriously hurt.
What to say
"I'm not comfortable providing a recorded statement at this time. I'll provide the facts of the accident in writing."
3. The Broad Medical Authorization
They send you a medical release form that gives them access to your entire medical history — not just records from the accident. They're fishing for pre-existing conditions so they can argue your back pain started years ago, not from the crash.
What to say
"I'll provide medical records related to injuries from this accident. I'm not signing a blanket authorization for my full medical history."
4. Downplaying Your Injuries
"You look like you're doing great!" The adjuster is friendly, upbeat, and subtly suggesting you're not that hurt. Everything you say in these conversations is noted. If you mention you went grocery shopping, that becomes evidence you're functional and your injury claim is exaggerated.
What to say
"My medical providers are documenting my condition. I'd prefer to let the medical records speak for themselves."
5. Delaying the Claim
Requests for "additional documentation," transferred to a new adjuster, unreturned calls. Delay is a weapon. Every state has a statute of limitations, and the longer you wait, the more pressure builds to accept a lower offer. Meanwhile, your bills pile up.
What to say
"I need a response by [specific date]. If I don't hear back, I'll be consulting with an attorney about next steps."
6. Blaming You for Partial Fault
"Were you on your phone?" "How fast were you going?" The adjuster floats the idea that you share blame. In comparative negligence states, your payout is reduced by your percentage of fault. If they pin 30% on you, a $100,000 claim becomes $70,000.
What to say
"The police report documents the facts of the accident. I'm not going to speculate about fault."
7. The Package Deal on Property Damage
They offer to settle your vehicle damage and injury claim together in one lump sum. The property damage number looks reasonable, which makes the total feel fair. But the injury portion is buried and dramatically undervalued. Once you sign, both claims are closed.
What to say
"I want to handle the property damage claim and the injury claim separately. They're two different issues with different timelines."
When to Involve a Lawyer
Not every fender-bender requires an attorney. But if any of the following apply to your situation, you are likely leaving money on the table by negotiating alone:
- You went to the ER, saw a specialist, or are still receiving treatment
- The adjuster is already using tactics from this list
- The other driver's insurance is disputing fault or claiming you were partially responsible
- You missed work or cannot return to the same job
- The insurance company is stalling and you are running out of patience — or savings
Most personal injury attorneys work on contingency, meaning they only get paid if you win. A free consultation costs you nothing and tells you whether your case is worth pursuing with professional help. Read more in our guide on what to do after a car accident.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to talk to the other driver's insurance adjuster?
No. You are not legally required to give a recorded statement or answer detailed questions from the at-fault driver's insurance company. You should report the accident to your own insurer, but you can decline to speak with the other side — especially before consulting a lawyer.
Can I negotiate with the insurance adjuster myself?
You can, and for minor accidents with no injuries, it sometimes makes sense. But if you have any medical treatment beyond an ER visit, or if the adjuster is already using tactics from this list, you are negotiating against a professional whose job is to minimize your payout. An attorney levels that playing field.
How long do I have to file an insurance claim after an accident?
Your own policy usually requires prompt notice — within days, not weeks. For a claim against the other driver, the statute of limitations varies by state (typically 2-4 years for personal injury). But waiting weakens your case. Evidence disappears, witnesses forget, and the insurer will use the delay against you.
What if the adjuster's settlement offer seems fair?
Get a second opinion before accepting. Many personal injury attorneys offer free case evaluations. They can tell you whether the offer accounts for future medical costs, lost earning capacity, and pain and suffering — factors adjusters routinely leave out of initial offers.
Don't Negotiate Alone
Every lawyer in our directory offers free consultations and works on contingency — you pay nothing unless you win.
Find a Lawyer Near You