Independent ratings · Not affiliated with any law firm · Every ranking is earned
90
Excellent

Wagner Reese

11939 N Meridian St, Carmel, IN 46032

Get a free consultation with Wagner Reese

Enter your info and they'll reach out to you. No commitment required.

What happens next:

1. Wagner Reese receives your info securely.

2. They call you within 1 hour during business hours.

3. Your free consultation is completely confidential — no obligation.

What type of accident?

1/5
Google Rating
4.93/5
521 reviews
Accident Reviews Analyzed
60
by our AI, so you don't have to

Our AI read 61 of this firm's written Google reviews (spanning Jul 2014–Jul 2026); 60 were about accident/injury cases and were used to score this firm, out of 521 total Google reviews (many are ratings-only with no written text).

What Clients Say

Clients consistently praise responsive communication, dedication to maximizing settlements, and compassionate handling of injury and accident cases. Multiple reviewers mention car accident and personal injury matters resolved with favorable outcomes.

Client Review Highlights

96
Fights for clients
98
Communication
70
Client focus

Scores 0–100 derived from FMAL's analysis of client reviews. 70+ = strong signal. These are algorithmic estimates, not verified statements of fact.

Wagner Reese, Jeff Gibson and Lana went above and beyond for our daughter. They made our family feel like real people and not just another case number.

Clients consistently praise responsive communication, dedication to maximizing settlements, and compassionate handling of injury and accident cases. Multiple reviewers mention car accident and personal injury matters resolved with favorable outcomes.

FMAL Score Breakdown

The bars show the raw quality of each signal. The overall score also weighs how much evidence backs it.

Google rating
99
Review sentiment
94
Case results
73
Communication
98
Fights for clients
96

Why 90? High confidence — based on 60 accident-case reviews plus verified data.

Accident Types Handled

Based on what real clients describe in their reviews and the firm's verified results. “Primary” = a core focus by client volume.

Car AccidentPrimary
$5.5M5 client reviews
Truck Accident
$4.0Mverified result
Wrongful Death
1 client review
Pedestrian Accident
1 client review

Track Record

Verified motor-vehicle-accident results published by the firm.

$5.5M
Largest result
6+
Verified results
29+ years
In practice

Firm Details

Practice Areas: Car Accident, Truck Accident, Pedestrian Accident, Wrongful Death
Languages: English
Free Consultation: Yes
Contingency Fee: Yes — no upfront cost
Experience: 29+ years
About:

Wagner Reese is a personal injury law firm in Carmel, IN representing accident victims in car accident, truck accident, pedestrian accident, wrongful death cases. It holds a 4.93/5 rating across 521 Google reviews.

Offices:
IN — Carmel
11939 N Meridian St, Carmel, IN 46032
5 · 74 reviews
IN — Indianapolis
201 N Illinois St 16th Floor, Indianapolis, IN 46204
4.9 · 130 reviews
IN — Evansville
815 John St Ste 110, Evansville, IN 47713
4.6 · 11 reviews
IN — Fort Wayne
111 W Berry St #211, Fort Wayne, IN 46802
5 · 42 reviews
IN — West Lafayette
101 Foundry Dr Ste 1200-14, West Lafayette, IN 47906
5 · 3 reviews
IL — Champaign
701 Devonshire Dr Ste C17, Champaign, IL 61820
5 · 1 reviews

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Wagner Reese offer free consultations?+

Yes. Wagner Reese offers free initial consultations for accident victims in Carmel, Indiana. You can discuss your case at no cost before deciding to hire them.

Does Wagner Reese work on contingency?+

Yes. Wagner Reese works on a contingency fee basis — you pay nothing upfront and they only collect a fee if they win your case.

What types of cases does Wagner Reese handle?+

Wagner Reese handles car accident, truck accident, pedestrian accident cases in Carmel, Indiana. Visit their profile for the full list of practice areas and to check if they handle your specific type of accident.

What is Wagner Reese's FMAL Score?+

Wagner Reese has an FMAL Score of 90 out of 100. Our AI reads every accident-case Google review and the firm's documented case results; the score combines review sentiment (42%), client-experience factors like communication and fighting for maximum compensation (36%), and verified case results (22%). No firm can pay to change their score.

Is this your firm?

Claim your profile to correct firm details, practice areas, and contact info. Claims are free and do not affect your FMAL Score.

Claim or Correct This Profile